Pink Eye vs Stye: What’s the Difference and How to Fix

When your eyes feel uncomfortable and look a bit pink, you might wonder whether it’s pink eye or a stye.

Pink eye, or conjunctivitis, happens when the conjunctiva gets inflamed due to an infection or allergies, causing redness, swelling, and discharge.

A stye, on the other hand, is a painful bump on your eyelid caused by a blocked oil gland.

Let’s take a closer look at how these two styles, pink eye vs stye eye, differ. 

But before jumping into details, let’s first understand these types.

Pink Eye

Conjunctivitis, often termed “pink eye,involves the inflammation of the conjunctiva, the clear membrane that lines your eyelid and covers the white part of your eyeball.

You’ll see redness, puffiness, and discharge. You need to know if your pink eye is viral, bacterial, or allergic, as this will determine what you do next.

  • Viral pink eye is often associated with upper respiratory infections like colds and is spread through airborne droplets.
  • Bacterial pink eye is caused by staphylococcal or streptococcal bacteria that are found on your skin or in your respiratory tract.
  • Allergic conjunctivitis occurs when you’re exposed to allergens like pollen, pet dander, or dust.

Research shows it affects about 6 million cases per year in the U.S., mostly caused by viruses or bacteria.

Stye Eye

Now let’s talk about styes. A stye is a sore protrusion along the border of the eyelid that results from a localized infection.

They’re those sore bumps that pop up on the edge of your eyelid due to a local infection. Unlike pink eye, a stye is caused by blocked oil glands or infected hair follicles. And it affects about 1 in 10 people during their lifetime.

See also  What Does It Mean When My Stomach Is Hard

You have two types of styes: external and internal.

The external stye is visible on the outer eyelid, the internal one is hidden under the inner lid. Both can be quite uncomfortable and may even affect your vision for a short time.

Pink Eye Symptoms

Here are the signs to look out for:

  • Redness in the eyes

This one’s pretty obvious.

  • Puffiness in the eyelid

Often comes with redness.

  • Eye discharge

This varies viral pink eye has watery discharge and bacterial pink eye has thicker secretion.

  • Crusty eyelids in the morning.
  • That icky feeling like something’s stuck in your eye.
  • Light sensitivity, which can be worse in bright places.

These symptoms can really disrupt your daily activities, but catching them early means you can get the right care and relief fast.

stye eye

Stye Symptoms

Styes have their own set of symptoms, different from pink eye. Here’s what to look out for:

  • A red, painful bump

It looks like a boil or pimple on your eyelid.

  • Swollen eyelid

This can get quite big and uncomfortable.

  • Light sensitivity and tenderness

You might struggle to open your eyes fully.

  • Crusting and discharge around the eyelid area, which impacts cleanliness.

Not only are these symptoms uncomfortable, but they can also disrupt your daily life.

Pink Eye vs. Styes: Key Differences

Although pink eye and styes share the same symptoms of redness and discomfort, they’re not the same. Pink eye comes with watery eyes, crusty eyelids, and redness. Depending on whether it’s viral or bacterial, the discharge varies. viral has clear fluid, bacterial has a yellowish-green tint.

A stye is that painful bump on your eyelid due to an infection of the oil glands. Knowing these signs is key to proper diagnosis and treatment.

Here’s the table for key differences:

FeaturePink Eye (Conjunctivitis)Stye (Hordeolum)
CauseViral, bacterial, or allergic reactionsBacterial infection, usually involving Staphylococcus
AppearanceRedness in the whites of the eye and watery or sticky dischargeSwollen, red lump near the eyelid, resembling a pimple
LocationAffects the conjunctiva (outer eye membrane)Found on or near the eyelid
SymptomsRedness, itching, burning, discharge, tearingPain, tenderness, swelling, redness, localized bump
Contagious?Yes (if viral or bacterial)Rarely contagious
TreatmentAntibacterial drops (if bacterial): cool compresses, antihistamines for allergiesWarm compresses, drainage if needed
Healing TimeUsually 7-10 daysTypically resolves within a few days to a week
Vision ImpactMinimal: may cause temporary blurred vision due to dischargeMinimal: rarely affects vision unless severe swelling
PreventionGood hygiene, avoid sharing personal items, hand washingClean hands, avoid touching or rubbing eyes

Causes and Risk Factors

Both pink eye and styes can be caused by various factors, from poor hygiene to environmental triggers. Here are the common causes and risk factors:

  1. Conjunctivitis: It comes in different forms, whether allergic, infectious, or chemical and each has its own culprits.
  2. Chemical conjunctivitis: This is caused by irritants like pollution, chlorine in pools, or harsh chemicals.
  3. Young children: They’re more prone to bacterial conjunctivitis.
See also  Why Is My Eyesight Getting Worse?

For styes, poor cleaning around the eyelids or conditions like blepharitis (inflammation of the eyelid edges) can cause trouble.

How Pink Eye & Styes Affect Your Eyes

The main symptom of pink eye is conjunctivitis, which leads to redness and irritation. While it’s uncomfortable, it doesn’t threaten your vision.

However, some types, like viral conjunctivitis, are highly contagious and can spread fast.

On the other hand, a stye can really affect your ocular health. It’s that painful bump on your eyelid that leads to inflammation, redness, and sensitivity.

This happens when bacteria thrive due to blocked oil glands, resulting in pus-filled bumps. Styes can appear suddenly and may rupture on their own and heal without intervention.

Treatment Options for Pink Eye

Treating pink eye depends on the diagnosis. If it’s bacterial conjunctivitis, your doctor will likely prescribe antibiotic eye drops to treat the infection.

Viral pink eye, being contagious, often clears up on its own. Using artificial tears and cold compresses can help relieve symptoms.

For allergic conjunctivitis, flushing out irritants with artificial tears and using over-the-counter antihistamines can help reduce redness and itching.

If symptoms are severe or persistent, your doctor may prescribe steroid-based eye drops to reduce inflammation.

Learn More: Why Do My Eyelashes Hurt?

How to Treat a Stye

Treating a stye is often done through home remedies. A warm compress is super easy to make. Just warm up a damp towel in the microwave or soak it in hot water, then squeeze out the excess. Applying this warm compress several times a day can help drain and heal the tissue.

If the stye doesn’t clear up after 3-4 weeks, it’s time to see a doctor. Sometimes a doctor may need to lance and drain it or prescribe antibiotics if there’s an infection.

Knowing your treatment options when you have a stye can help.

Prevention Method

To avoid pink eye and styes good hygiene habits are your best friends. Here are some:

  • Wash your hands

Before touching your eyes.

  • Don’t touch or rub your eyes

This prevents transferring of infectious agents.

  • Keep personal items personal

Don’t share makeup, towels or pillows.

  • Clean common areas

Especially if someone in your household has pink eye.

    See also  How to Make Cold Less Miserable: 7 Simple Remedies

    Follow these tips from eye care experts and you’ll reduce your risk of eye infections.

    When to See a Doctor

    If the color of your eye turns to shades beyond mild redness don’t hesitate to see a doctor. Early detection and prompt treatment is key to managing pink eye and preventing complications.

    In case of severe symptoms if they persist beyond 48 hours or affects your vision see a doctor ASAP. Quick action can prevent problems and speed up healing.

    So there you have it. Pink eye is the inflammation of the conjunctiva, styes are sore bumps caused by bacterial infection in the oil glands of the eyelid.

    John Harvey
    John Harvey

    John Harvey, M.D., M.P.H., is an Internal Medicine physician and professor of public health. His work focuses on improving healthcare quality and cost efficiency through policy-driven research. He holds both a Doctor of Medicine and a Master of Public Health, and completed advanced fellowship training in health policy and healthcare delivery.